fid = dHash vs source (≤100 passes) · sonnet = production judge · gemini = second opinion. Flag any composite that looks wrong even if marked PASS.
room / variant
pass
rate
kitchen/primary
5/7
71%
tub_portrait/letterbox
2/11
18%
r4_bedroom/primary
3/5
60%
r3_living/primary
4/10
40%
r3_living/minimal
4/10
40%
vanity/primary
0/10
0%
tub_portrait/primary
0/10
0%
215e19_kitchen0/primary
3/3
100%
215e19_living1/primary
2/3
67%
215e19_dining2/letterbox
1/3
33%
215e19_bedroom3/primary
1/3
33%
215e19_bathroom4/primary
1/3
33%
161hudson_living0/primary
0/3
0%
161hudson_dining1/primary
0/3
0%
161hudson_kitchen2/primary
1/3
33%
161hudson_bedroom3/primary
3/3
100%
161hudson_bathroom4/primary
0/3
0%
r3_living/lit
4/5
80%
kitchen/lit
1/3
33%
161hudson2_living0/lit
2/3
67%
161hudson2_kitchen1/lit
0/3
0%
161hudson2_bedroom2/lit
1/3
33%
161hudson2_bathroom3/lit
0/3
0%
161hudson2_living4/lit
1/3
33%
215e19b_living0/primary
2/3
67%
215e19b_dining1/letterbox
1/3
33%
215e19b_bedroom2/lit
2/3
67%
215e19b_living3/letterbox
0/3
0%
215e19b_living4/primary
1/3
33%
101warrenst_living0/lit
2/3
67%
101warrenst_amenity1/letterbox
2/3
67%
101warrenst_dining2/lit
2/3
67%
101warrenst_hallway3/letterbox
2/3
67%
101warrenst_kitchen4/lit
3/3
100%
123e61st_hallway1/primary
3/3
100%
123e61st_living0/lit
0/3
0%
123e61st_bedroom2/primary
2/3
67%
123e61st_bathroom3/primary
3/3
100%
123e61st_amenity4/primary
2/3
67%
145w86th_dining0/primary
1/3
33%
15hudsonyards_living0/lit
0/3
0%
15hudsonyards_kitchen1/lit
0/3
0%
15hudsonyards_dining2/lit
0/3
0%
15hudsonyards_bedroom3/lit
3/3
100%
15hudsonyards_office4/letterbox
0/3
0%
20clintonst_bedroom0/primary
0/3
0%
20clintonst_kitchen1/primary
1/3
33%
205e63rd_living0/lit
1/3
33%
205e63rd_bedroom1/primary
2/3
67%
205e63rd_bathroom2/letterbox
0/3
0%
205e63rd_amenity3/letterbox
1/3
33%
205e63rd_living4/lit
2/3
67%
2090madisonave_living0/primary
2/3
67%
2090madisonave_dining1/primary
0/3
0%
2090madisonave_bedroom2/primary
1/3
33%
2090madisonave_kitchen3/primary
1/3
33%
2090madisonave_bathroom4/primary
1/3
33%
217w57th_living0/lit
2/3
67%
217w57th_dining1/lit
3/3
100%
217w57th_office2/lit
1/3
33%
217w57th_bedroom4/lit
1/3
33%
217w57th_hallway3/letterbox
1/3
33%
228w17th_living0/primary
1/3
33%
228w17th_kitchen1/primary
2/3
67%
228w17th_bathroom2/letterbox
2/3
67%
228w17th_bedroom3/primary
0/3
0%
228w17th_living4/primary
2/3
67%
264w77th_kitchen0/primary
0/3
0%
264w77th_bedroom1/primary
3/3
100%
264w77th_bedroom2/primary
3/3
100%
303e57th_living0/primary
3/3
100%
303e57th_dining1/primary
1/3
33%
303e57th_kitchen2/primary
3/3
100%
303e57th_bedroom3/primary
2/3
67%
303e57th_bathroom4/primary
0/3
0%
309e108th_living0/lit
3/3
100%
309e108th_bedroom1/primary
3/3
100%
309e108th_kitchen2/primary
2/3
67%
309e108th_hallway3/primary
3/3
100%
309e108th_bathroom4/primary
2/3
67%
311e75th_bedroom0/lit
0/3
0%
323w43rd_kitchen1/primary
2/3
67%
323w43rd_living0/primary
1/3
33%
323w43rd_bedroom2/primary
3/3
100%
323w43rd_living3/primary
3/3
100%
323w43rd_living4/primary
3/3
100%
345w13th_living0/lit
3/3
100%
345w13th_kitchen1/primary
1/3
33%
345w13th_dining2/lit
2/3
67%
345w13th_bedroom3/lit
1/3
33%
345w13th_bathroom4/primary
3/3
100%
392centralpark_living0/lit
1/3
33%
392centralpark_kitchen1/lit
2/3
67%
4e73rd_hallway0/primary
2/3
67%
4e73rd_living1/primary
1/3
33%
4e73rd_dining2/primary
0/3
0%
4e73rd_bathroom3/letterbox
1/3
33%
4e73rd_bedroom4/primary
1/3
33%
4staplest_dining0/lit
3/3
100%
4staplest_living1/lit
2/3
67%
4staplest_living2/primary
2/3
67%
4staplest_living3/primary
0/3
0%
4staplest_living4/primary
3/3
100%
410centralpark_kitchen1/letterbox
0/3
0%
410centralpark_hallway0/primary
0/3
0%
410centralpark_bedroom2/letterbox
3/3
100%
410centralpark_hallway3/letterbox
2/3
67%
410centralpark_hallway4/letterbox
3/3
100%
424e115th_bedroom0/primary
0/3
0%
424e115th_living1/primary
0/3
0%
424e115th_kitchen2/primary
2/3
67%
424e115th_bathroom3/letterbox
0/3
0%
424e115th_kitchen4/primary
0/3
0%
424e115th_kitchen4 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 51 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: presenter overlaps/intersects with refrigerator and countertop, appears to be standing behind furniture rather than fully on clear open floor · lower legs partially obscured by counter, feet not clearly visible on floor
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room · Presenter casts no realistic shadows
424e115th_kitchen4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 47 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears too large relative to the door and refrigerator, suggesting oversized scale · presenter is positioned partially in front of/overlapping the refrigerator and cabinets, not on fully clear open floor · lower legs/feet placement relative to floor looks slightly ambiguous against the rug edge
424e115th_kitchen4 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 49 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's body overlaps/intersects the refrigerator, appearing partially behind it rather than fully on open floor · Feet/lower legs partially obscured by rug and proximity to fridge
424e115th_kitchen2 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 85 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Feet/lower legs obscured by rug edge cropping, standing on rug rather than clear floor · Person positioned close to counter/cabinets with limited clearance, reads slightly pasted-in due to lighting mismatch
424e115th_kitchen2 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 56 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: subtle drop shadow on door slightly stylized but overall consistent · person stands close to door but feet are visible on floor mat, acceptable placement
gemini: lighting on presenter doesn't match room lighting · unrealistic generic drop shadow under presenter gives a cutout look
424e115th_bathroom3 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 106 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: room appears widened/stretched compared to original narrow bathroom framing · ceiling and wall proportions altered, camera framing changed from portrait crop · presenter is oversized relative to the tub, sink, and toilet at same depth
gemini: room was widened · changed camera framing
424e115th_bathroom3 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 89 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Room framing widened/extended vs image 1 — extra left wall area with toilet paper holder not present in original crop · Ceiling vent and proportions shifted slightly, suggesting altered camera framing rather than exact match
gemini: room was extended/widened · framing/crop changed · object added to wall
424e115th_bedroom0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 70 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's legs overlap/intersect with the green sofa and appear to stand behind it rather than fully on clear open floor · Lower legs partially occluded by sofa, violating unobstructed full-body visibility requirement
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room lighting · Presenter shadow is inaccurate for the light source
424e115th_bathroom3 / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 108 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs overlap/intersect with the vanity cabinet and toilet, standing behind furniture rather than fully on clear open floor · Feet/lower legs not fully visible due to occlusion by toilet and vanity
gemini: presenter not reflected in mirror · lighting on person does not match room
424e115th_kitchen2 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 72 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person's feet obscured by rug edge/shadow, slightly reduces ground contact clarity · otherwise consistent with room and reference outfit
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room lighting · Presenter lacks realistic shadows · Reads as a pasted cutout due to lighting mismatch
424e115th_living1 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 52 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Person's feet/legs overlap with desk and chair, which are between him and the camera · Lower legs partially obscured by desk
424e115th_living1 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 79 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Desk and chair appear to be behind/overlapping presenter's arm and body creating unclear depth relationship · Feet/lower legs positioned oddly close to desk edge, ambiguous overlap with desk
gemini: Room was horizontally widened · Camera framing changed
424e115th_living1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 64 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's legs and body overlap/intersect with the desk and chair rather than standing fully on clear floor · Person appears pasted in front of desk with shadow inconsistent with room lighting · Slight cutout/flat appearance suggesting composited figure rather than naturally standing in the space
424e115th_bedroom0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 68 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Sofa's front edge overlaps/intersects with presenter's legs, placing furniture between camera and subject · Lower legs partially obscured by sofa arm, not fully visible
gemini: Presenter looks pasted on due to inconsistent lighting and generic shadow.
424e115th_bedroom0 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 77 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's legs overlap/intersect with the green sofa and coffee table, which are between them and the camera · Feet/lower legs not fully visible due to occlusion by coffee table and sofa · Shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting, giving a slightly pasted-in look
gemini: Lighting on presenter is too frontal, inconsistent with room's overhead light. · Presenter's shadow is a generic drop shadow, not a realistic cast shadow.
410centralpark_bedroom2 / letterbox · t3 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini —
410centralpark_hallway4 / letterbox · t3 PASS
fid 57 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting is brighter than the room · Shadow under presenter is soft and generic
410centralpark_hallway4 / letterbox · t2 PASS
fid 91 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Room was extended/widened · Changed aspect ratio/framing
gemini: Presenter lighting is cooler than room lighting · Presenter shadow doesn't match room light sources
410centralpark_bedroom2 / letterbox · t2 PASS
fid 59 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
410centralpark_bedroom2 / letterbox · t1 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Shadow under presenter is artificial · Presenter lighting is slightly flat and does not perfectly match the room's ambient light.
410centralpark_hallway0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 112 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Sign text on desk changed from 'VISITORS MUST BE ANNOUNCED NO SMOKING' to different illegible text, altering room decor · Concierge figure and laptop/objects behind desk removed/replaced, altering desk contents beyond just adding presenter
gemini: original person behind desk removed · sign on right side of desk was replaced
410centralpark_hallway0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 116 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Scene appears horizontally mirrored versus image 1 (sign text reversed, layout flipped) · Desk attendant visible in image 1 is missing/removed in image 2
gemini: Original person at desk was removed
410centralpark_kitchen1 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 112 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's body overlaps/stands in front of the refrigerator and cabinet, blocking part of the kitchen units rather than standing fully on clear open floor · Feet are close to the kitchen alcove threshold, reducing sense of standing in open room space
gemini: room was widened · original image crop/framing was changed · walls were extended
sonnet: presenter's body overlaps/intersects with dishwasher, sink counter, and refrigerator - furniture is between/behind him but he stands too close/overlapping the counter edge · lower legs partially obscured by appearing to merge with dishwasher front panel · no clear open floor gap shown between presenter and kitchen units
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room lighting · Presenter casts no shadow · Presenter looks pasted on / like a cutout
410centralpark_hallway0 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 116 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Original reception desk, front desk person, floral arrangement position altered/obscured; sign text now illegible/altered · Presenter is oversized relative to the doorway and desk depth compared to original scale reference · Presenter stands in the doorway threshold rather than clearly on open floor inside the room, partially blocking the frame
sonnet: Room framing widened/altered compared to image 1, extra wall space added on left side not present in original crop · Presenter's lower legs/feet overlap with the dishwasher and refrigerator, placing him inside the kitchen counter line rather than fully on open floor · Presenter stands directly against the cabinetry/appliance plane, reading as pasted in front of the fixtures rather than naturally standing in open room space
gemini: invented wall to the right of presenter · removed room view through doorway
4staplest_living4 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 59 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
4staplest_living3 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 66 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's lower legs/feet overlap with the ottoman/pouf in front of him, making him appear to stand partially behind furniture rather than fully on clear open floor · Slight distortion in watermark text rendering compared to source, but this is a pre-existing watermark issue not an added element
4staplest_living3 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 61 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Sotheby's logo text is garbled/distorted in image 2 compared to clean logo in image 1 · Presenter's lower legs/feet are obscured by ottoman and armchair in foreground, violating clear floor visibility requirement · Presenter appears to float slightly without clear grounding shadow matching room lighting
4staplest_living3 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 59 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Lower legs/feet appear to overlap with ottoman/chair area in front of him · Person placement close to furniture with minimal clear floor buffer · Shadow beneath figure looks faint/inconsistent with room lighting
gemini: Watermark not removed
4staplest_living2 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 64 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
4staplest_living2 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Sotheby's watermark text rendering slightly altered/blurred compared to image 1, but same logo present
gemini: room has been horizontally stretched/widened
4staplest_living1 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 57 · sonnet pass · gemini —
sonnet: Coffee table appears directly in front of presenter's legs, creating slight overlap/proximity between furniture and presenter's lower body
4staplest_living2 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 60 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs overlap/intersect with the fur-draped chair in the foreground, breaking the 'no furniture between subject and camera' rule · Lower legs are partially obscured by the chair rather than fully visible
gemini: presenter is not the reference person · presenter placed behind foreground furniture
4staplest_dining0 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 56 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: room has been widened/stretched · floor texture altered
4staplest_living1 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 60 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: person is behind furniture
4staplest_living1 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 48 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's feet/lower legs are obscured by the coffee table and bench, which are positioned between the presenter and the camera
gemini: foreground furniture between camera and presenter
4staplest_dining0 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 81 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: Sotheby's watermark still visible top-left, contradicting watermark_gone claim · dining chair partially overlaps presenter's leg area, breaking clear-floor requirement
4staplest_dining0 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 66 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Poorly rendered shadow · Presenter lighting is artificial
4e73rd_bedroom4 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 61 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: desk edge is at same depth as presenter and appears to touch/overlap his hand/arm area, creating ambiguous contact between furniture and figure · lower legs partially obscured by desk base proximity
gemini: Lighting on presenter doesn't match room · Presenter shadow is generic
4e73rd_bedroom4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 64 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: desk corner overlaps/intersects with presenter's leg area, meaning furniture is between camera and part of the person · lower legs partially obscured by desk edge
gemini: room was horizontally stretched · left wall was extended · changed image crop/framing
4e73rd_bathroom3 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 78 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's feet not visible and appears to be standing very close to/overlapping the vanity leg area · figure placed in narrow space between vanity and door, feels tight against fixtures rather than clear open floor
gemini: Presenter's reflection is missing from mirror
4e73rd_dining2 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 75 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Table and chairs are positioned in front of presenter's legs, creating an intersection where the table edge and chairs overlap with his lower body/legs · Feet and lower legs are obscured by the dining table and chairs in foreground · Person appears to be standing behind/inside the table setup rather than fully on clear open floor
4e73rd_living1 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 76 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Coffee table and stone cube furniture appear to be directly in front of/overlapping presenter's legs, no clear floor gap visible between presenter and furniture · presenter placed close to camera but feet position relative to furniture creates ambiguous depth/overlap
4e73rd_bedroom4 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 51 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: desk edge is at same depth as presenter and slightly overlaps near his hand/leg area
4e73rd_bathroom3 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 83 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter is standing on a rug/area near the vanity but positioned very close to the doorway edge, partially overlapping the open door plane · Legs/feet placement near the door frame reads slightly ambiguous in depth relative to the door · Otherwise wardrobe, scale, and room architecture are consistent
gemini: rug added
4e73rd_bathroom3 / letterbox · t1 PASS
fid 76 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
4e73rd_dining2 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 60 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's legs are obscured by dining chairs, breaking the 'fully on clear open floor' requirement · Table/chairs are positioned between presenter and camera at lower body level, creating overlap with furniture
4e73rd_hallway0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 85 · sonnet pass · gemini —
4e73rd_dining2 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 73 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's lower legs/feet are occluded by the dining chairs and table in front of him · Chairs are positioned between the presenter and the camera, violating unobstructed placement
gemini: presenter is behind furniture · presenter's feet/lower legs are not visible
4e73rd_living1 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 70 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person's feet placed slightly close to coffee table/cube furniture but no overlap · otherwise consistent with reference room and outfit
gemini: Presenter lighting is slightly too flat/even compared to the room's overhead lights. · Shadows under presenter are a bit weak.
4e73rd_living1 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 126 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: subtle soft-edge cutout look around presenter's silhouette · shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with room lighting
sonnet: person's head overlaps/blends into the curved staircase wall behind, creating a merged silhouette · lower legs/feet placement ambiguous relative to bench, appears close to intersecting bench line · figure reads slightly pasted-in due to lighting mismatch with dim hallway
4e73rd_hallway0 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: room was widened to create space
392centralpark_kitchen1 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 59 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter's lighting is flat and does not match the room's strong window light. · Shadow under presenter is generic and does not realistically correspond to room lighting.
392centralpark_kitchen1 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 89 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with room lighting · slight edge softness around presenter suggesting composited cutout
gemini: Presenter lighting is inconsistent with the room's light sources · Presenter lacks a cast shadow, making him appear pasted on
392centralpark_living0 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 81 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: kitchen island appears to pass in front of presenter's legs, partially occluding lower body · shadow/grounding beneath feet is weak, slight floating appearance
gemini: Room has been widened, changing the original framing
392centralpark_living0 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 76 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's feet/lower legs are occluded by the sofa/chaise in front, violating clear-floor visibility requirement · Presenter appears to stand slightly behind the sofa rather than fully on open floor closer to camera
gemini: Room was artificially extended on the right side, changing the wall and TV dimensions.
392centralpark_kitchen1 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 50 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: dining table and chairs are positioned in front of the presenter, overlapping his lower body/legs · legs/feet not fully visible due to table and chair in front
392centralpark_living0 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 117 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's arm appears to overlap/intersect with the bar stool behind him · Feet placement near kitchen island edge is ambiguous, partially obscured by island counter · Person stands close to island counter which may be between him and camera at that angle
gemini: TV and mount removed from wall · Artwork removed from wall · Hanging chain light fixture over dining area removed
345w13th_bathroom4 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 64 · sonnet pass · gemini —
345w13th_bathroom4 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 63 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: feet obscured by rug edge/shadow, lower legs not fully clear · slight flattening of tile texture behind figure suggests mild cutout blending
gemini: Room lighting has been significantly altered from dramatic downlights to flat, even light · Wall and ceiling textures appear restyled/softened vs image 1 · Reflection in mirror is altered/blurred out
345w13th_bathroom4 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 45 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears slightly flat/cutout-like against background · shadow/lighting on presenter doesn't fully match warm ambient room lighting
gemini: Background photo has been heavily filtered/restyled with a sketch effect
345w13th_bedroom3 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 57 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Room framing/proportions altered - right side appears widened/extended compared to original crop · Desk and computer monitor appear shifted/resized relative to original · Presenter appears oversized compared to nearby desk and chair
gemini: Invented wall section on right · Altered framing/crop
345w13th_kitchen1 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 58 · sonnet pass · gemini —
345w13th_bedroom3 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 50 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: figure is positioned partially through the open doorway/threshold rather than fully on open bedroom floor · desk chair is close to the figure creating slight ambiguity of furniture between camera and subject
gemini: Presenter lighting doesn't match room lighting · Shadow is generic and inconsistent with light source
345w13th_dining2 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 55 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person stands slightly close to metal pole/column, minor overlap of shadow area near pillar · lighting on presenter slightly flatter than ambient warm room light
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room lighting · Missing contact shadows under presenter
345w13th_living0 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 69 · sonnet pass · gemini —
345w13th_dining2 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 116 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person's shadow/lighting slightly inconsistent with warm ambient light of room · edges around figure show slight cutout/composite look
gemini: room color and lighting were altered · chandelier lights were dimmed
345w13th_dining2 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting is cooler than room lighting · Shadow is artificial · Presenter looks like a cutout due to lighting mismatch
345w13th_kitchen1 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 73 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: a wooden door was added on the right side of image 2 that doesn't exist in image 1 · presenter's lower legs/feet are obscured by the kitchen island counter in front of him · framing/crop slightly altered from original, showing added wall/door area not present in source
gemini: invented door and wall on right · presenter lighting doesn't match room
345w13th_living0 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 61 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person's feet/lower legs are close to sofa but not overlapping, placement borderline near couch armrest · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and frontal, inconsistent with the strong backlighting from room windows. · Shadow under presenter is generic and doesn't fully ground him in the scene.
345w13th_kitchen1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 60 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's lower legs/feet are obscured by the kitchen island, breaking the 'clear open floor with feet visible' requirement · Person stands directly behind the island counter with the island between him and the camera at that depth
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and does not match the room's lighting sources · Shadows under presenter are weak/unrealistic
345w13th_living0 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 66 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: slight flatness/lighting mismatch suggests pasted cutout look · shadow beneath presenter is minimal compared to natural room lighting
gemini: Ceiling was vertically extended/invented, changing the image framing and room proportions. · Presenter appears pasted onto the image due to inconsistent lighting and a complete lack of shadows.
323w43rd_living4 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 81 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room lighting. · Shadow under presenter is weak and unrealistic.
323w43rd_living4 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 92 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
323w43rd_living4 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 87 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting is inconsistent with room lighting · Weak/unrealistic shadows under presenter
323w43rd_living3 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 80 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with lamp lighting direction · feet slightly ambiguous where rug meets floor but both visible
323w43rd_living3 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 66 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter inconsistent with room lighting direction · coffee table appears very close to presenter's legs, slightly ambiguous depth
gemini: person is placed behind furniture
323w43rd_bedroom2 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 61 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting is slightly brighter than room lighting. · Shadow under presenter is generic and soft.
323w43rd_living3 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 64 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears slightly cut off/close to camera framing at bottom, but feet visible · slight softness/blend around figure edges suggesting composite
gemini: person placed behind furniture
323w43rd_bedroom2 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 68 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: window sill/trim behind presenter's legs suggests slight depth misalignment near wall · shadow beneath presenter is minimal compared to lighting in room, slightly reducing grounded look
323w43rd_bedroom2 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 74 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
323w43rd_kitchen1 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 99 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and does not match the room's light sources · Presenter looks like a flat cutout rather than being integrated into the scene · Shadow under presenter is unconvincing
323w43rd_kitchen1 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 73 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting · lower legs partially blend with floor tone but feet visible
gemini: Lighting on presenter is slightly mismatched with the room's light sources · Presenter's shadow is weak and not fully convincing
323w43rd_living0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 71 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person's feet appear to overlap the edge of the flooring transition/rug line, but otherwise stands on open floor
323w43rd_living0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 67 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: counter/cabinet area appears shifted/enlarged compared to image 1, altering room framing · presenter is oversized relative to the cabinetry and counter beside him · presenter's body overlaps/intersects the counter and wine fridge instead of standing on clear open floor
323w43rd_living0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 85 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's feet/lower legs are obscured by the coffee table in front and appear cropped by the stove/cooktop in the foreground · Person stands very close to the cabinetry/counter edge, partially blending with the wine cooler unit rather than fully on clear open floor
323w43rd_kitchen1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 147 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: stove/range in foreground now overlaps in front of presenter's legs, blocking lower body · floor tile pattern and wear marks altered near presenter's feet · presenter appears to float slightly with no clear shadow grounding him to floor
gemini: Presenter lighting and shadows don't perfectly match room sources.
311e75th_bedroom0 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 70 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: person's legs are obscured/overlapping by the coffee table and sectional in front, no clear floor gap between presenter and furniture · lower legs not fully visible due to table position
gemini: room was distorted/widened · camera framing and aspect ratio changed
311e75th_bedroom0 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 83 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's legs overlap/intersect with the bed and appear positioned behind it rather than fully on clear open floor · Lower legs partially obscured by bed frame, violating full leg visibility requirement · Placement reads as slightly floating near the bed edge rather than naturally standing in open space
gemini: Room was artificially widened/extended · Presenter's lighting (harsh, frontal) does not match the room's ambient light (soft, from side window) · Presenter has an unnatural glow/halo effect
311e75th_bedroom0 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 81 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's legs are partially occluded by the bed frame/coffee table area, breaking the 'fully on clear open floor' requirement · Shadow beneath presenter is inconsistent with room lighting direction, contributing to a pasted-in look
gemini: Room has been horizontally stretched/distorted
309e108th_bathroom4 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 76 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: person overlaps/intersects vanity counter edge, appears to stand partially inside cabinet · lower legs partially obscured by counter, not fully visible on clear open floor
gemini: Missing reflection of presenter in mirror.
309e108th_bathroom4 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 75 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Missing presenter reflection in mirror. · Lighting on presenter is flat and does not match the room's light sources.
309e108th_bathroom4 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 63 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Wall extended on right · Window added on right · Door changed
309e108th_hallway3 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 65 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: room framing changed · ceiling was edited
309e108th_hallway3 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 62 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: presenter is not reflected in mirror · lighting on presenter does not match room · presenter casts no shadow
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room lighting · Presenter's floor reflection is weak and unnatural
309e108th_kitchen2 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 76 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: crop/framing changed from image 1 to image 2 (aspect ratio and camera angle differ, room appears widened with more wall/window visible on right side) · left portion of room with lower cabinet/countertop visible in image 1 replaced by a wooden surface/counter edge not present in original
gemini: Lighting on presenter is slightly different from room lighting · Presenter is not reflected in the shiny appliances
309e108th_bedroom1 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Lighting on presenter is too flat/frontal, not matching strong window light from the left · Shadow under presenter is weak and non-directional
309e108th_living0 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 75 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting doesn't match room lighting
309e108th_living0 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 72 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: cutout has flat, poorly blended edge lighting/shadow making it read as pasted rather than integrated into the room's depth
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room · Shadow under presenter is artificial
309e108th_living0 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 85 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting · feet placement slightly ambiguous relative to rug edge, appears to float slightly above floor line
gemini: Room was widened/outpainted to fit presenter
303e57th_bathroom4 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 98 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: presenter appears positioned inside/behind the tub-shower area, overlapping the shower glass door and tub edge rather than standing on open floor · lower legs/feet appear to be within the tub enclosure area, not clearly on open bathroom floor
303e57th_bathroom4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 75 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's feet/lower legs are obscured by the toilet, meaning the toilet is between him and the camera at that depth · Presenter appears oversized relative to the toilet and vanity, nearly as tall as the shower door frame in a way that exceeds a normal 5.5-6ft person given his proximity to the tub/toilet · He stands partially inside the tub/shower area rather than fully on open floor
303e57th_bathroom4 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 68 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's feet/lower legs are obscured, appearing to stand behind/inside the toilet, with the fixture between him and the camera
303e57th_bedroom3 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 89 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Left wall was extended/restyled with added paneling/closet doors that don't exist in image 1 · Overall room appears slightly reframed/widened on left side compared to original · Presenter's feet and lower legs are obscured by rug, not fully visible on clear floor · Presenter appears to stand slightly awkwardly close to bed corner, reducing natural placement
gemini: Wall/closet added on left · TV removed from left wall · Rug added
303e57th_bedroom3 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Presenter lighting is inconsistent with room lighting. · Presenter shadow is unrealistic. · Presenter appears pasted on due to poor lighting integration.
sonnet: Presenter's legs/feet overlap with the glass dining table and bench, obscuring lower body · Table is positioned between presenter and camera, violating clear line-of-sight placement rule · Shadow/grounding beneath feet is not clearly visible, giving slightly pasted-cutout appearance
gemini: wall has been altered/extended behind presenter · presenter is standing behind furniture
303e57th_dining1 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 61 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Missing shadows · Lighting on presenter does not match room
303e57th_living0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 84 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
303e57th_living0 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 94 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
303e57th_dining1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 54 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's feet are positioned at the height of the bench seat rather than on the floor, making him appear to be standing on/behind the bench instead of on open floor · The bench is directly between the presenter and the camera at leg height, creating an implausible floating/elevated stance
gemini: wall/corner painted over behind presenter · unrealistic lighting on presenter · presenter appears as a flat cutout · unrealistic shadow
303e57th_living0 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 84 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
264w77th_bedroom2 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 56 · sonnet pass · gemini —
264w77th_bedroom1 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 51 · sonnet pass · gemini —
sonnet: person appears slightly flat/cutout with soft edge blending against wall · shadow beneath presenter is minimal, reducing grounded feel
264w77th_bedroom2 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 45 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: slight flat cutout appearance with soft shadow, but stands on open floor with feet visible · lighting on figure slightly flatter than ambient room light
gemini: Lighting on presenter doesn't match room · Unrealistic shadow
gemini: Lighting on presenter is brighter and more direct than room's ambient light · Presenter's shadow is generic and unconvincing
264w77th_bedroom1 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 87 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: cutout has flat lighting/shadow inconsistent with room's warm light, giving pasted appearance · no cast shadow on floor beneath presenter
gemini: room widened · changed framing · presenter looks like a cutout
264w77th_kitchen0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 67 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's lower legs/feet overlap with dishwasher and cabinet base, not fully on clear open floor · Person stands very close to counter/cabinet edge, partially between kitchen fixtures rather than open floor space
sonnet: presenter overlaps/intersects with refrigerator and counter edge, not standing fully on clear open floor · lower legs partially obscured by counter, appears to float slightly near counter edge
gemini: Presenter lighting feels too generic and does not match the room's light sources. · Presenter's shadow is too soft and does not accurately reflect the overhead lighting. · Presenter appears slightly sharper than the background at the same depth.
264w77th_kitchen0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 49 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter overlaps/stands in front of refrigerator with body partially occluding it, appears pressed against the appliance rather than standing on open floor · Feet/lower legs not clearly visible on floor, giving a slightly pasted cutout look
228w17th_living4 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 81 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
228w17th_living4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 130 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Window sill/AC unit depth shortened and hallway proportions altered vs image 1 · Presenter is oversized relative to doorway and hallway width, appears too tall for the space · Presenter's feet/lower legs are not visible, obscured by rug, breaking contact with floor
gemini: Room was widened/outpainted · Watermark not removed
sonnet: Person's lower legs and feet overlap/intersect with the bed and appear to stand partly inside the bed area rather than fully on clear open floor
gemini: Presenter's pocket square is missing.
228w17th_bathroom2 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 42 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter is too large for the narrow hallway bathroom, appears oversized relative to sink/toilet/door · Presenter overlaps toilet and shower curtain area, not standing on fully clear open floor · Feet/lower legs partially obscured by toilet and bath mat placement, blocking a clean stance
gemini: watermark not removed · lighting on presenter is harsh and doesn't match room ambient light
228w17th_bedroom3 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 96 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's legs appear to overlap/intersect with the bed and possibly the nightstand area, not fully on clear open floor · Bed is directly behind/beside the presenter with no clear separation, making placement look slightly inserted rather than naturally standing in open space
228w17th_bedroom3 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 106 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's feet/legs are obscured by the bed, appears to be standing behind/inside the bed rather than on clear open floor · Watermark 'OneKe...' still visible in bottom right corner
gemini: presenter's lighting is inconsistent with the room's lighting · presenter appears as a flat cutout · unrealistic shadows
228w17th_bathroom2 / letterbox · t2 PASS
fid 30 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL
gemini: watermark not removed
228w17th_kitchen1 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 97 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's feet are obscured/overlapping with the wooden cart and floor mat, not standing on clear open floor · Lower legs partially blend into the mat shadow area, reducing clarity of full leg visibility · Placement is tight in the narrow galley space, causing near-overlap with cart shelf edge on the left
gemini: room has been artificially widened · background elements stretched/cloned to fill new space · new watermark added
228w17th_living0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 103 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: chair and table are behind/beside presenter but presenter stands too close to the doorway/wall plane, appearing pasted rather than naturally grounded · feet placement lacks shadow consistency with room lighting · watermark still visible bottom right
gemini: room has been artificially widened/extended · crop/framing changed · watermark not removed
228w17th_kitchen1 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: photo has been significantly re-lit, sharpened and color graded
228w17th_living0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 123 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs/feet overlap with the folding chair and glass table base, breaking clear-floor placement · Person stands close to camera in a way that partially blocks view of couch, reading slightly cutout-like · Watermark 'OneKe' still visible in bottom right corner
gemini: watermark not removed
228w17th_living0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 91 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: watermark 'OneKe' still visible bottom right · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting
gemini: Presenter's lighting doesn't perfectly match the room's light sources. · Shadow under presenter is somewhat generic and soft.
217w57th_hallway3 / letterbox · t3 PASS
fid 82 · sonnet pass · gemini —
217w57th_bedroom4 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting is too flat and doesn't match the strong directional light from the windows. · Shadow under presenter is a simple drop shadow, not a cast shadow from the windows.
217w57th_bedroom4 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 84 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet overlap in front of the bed and appear positioned where the bed frame/foot area would be, creating slight intersection with bed at right side · shadow beneath figure is minimal/inconsistent with strong window light, making placement feel slightly pasted
gemini: mismatched lighting on presenter · presenter shadow is unconvincing
217w57th_hallway3 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 138 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person cropped at knees, lower legs and feet not visible
gemini: Room was horizontally extended/outpainted · Changed framing / aspect ratio
217w57th_hallway3 / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 112 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Camera framing widened/zoomed out compared to image 1, revealing additional windows, a column, and double doors on the right not visible in original crop · Composition altered from portrait crop to wider view
gemini: Room was widened / framing changed · Architecture was invented (doors on right) · Exterior view was replaced
217w57th_bedroom4 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 85 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Feet/lower legs obscured by carpet shadow blending, appears slightly low contrast at floor contact point · Shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with strong window light, giving slight floating appearance
gemini: Presenter lacks a shadow, making him appear pasted on and not grounded in the environment.
217w57th_office2 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 79 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: desk chair and table edge overlap with presenter's body, breaking clear-floor rule · legs partially obscured by desk/chairs in front, no unobstructed sightline to camera · shadow/grounding looks slightly pasted, weak contact shadow under feet
gemini: Presenter is positioned behind furniture · Presenter's feet and lower legs are obscured by furniture
217w57th_office2 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 102 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: A plain white door was added on the left wall that is not present in image 1 · Presenter's feet/lower legs are obscured by the desk and chairs, breaking the 'clear floor' requirement · Person reads slightly cutout/pasted against the scene rather than fully integrated into depth
gemini: added door on left wall · room widened to the left · changed crop
217w57th_dining1 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 95 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: slight soft shadow/edge blending near feet suggests mild cutout look · figure positioned close to window plane but feet appear grounded on floor
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with light direction · person positioned close to window plane giving slightly flat cutout appearance
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room · Shadow is an artificial drop shadow
217w57th_office2 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 71 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person's feet/lower legs are not visible, obscured by desk/rug area shadow · slight flat cutout appearance with soft edge lighting mismatch
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room lighting · Shadow under presenter is unnatural
217w57th_dining1 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 66 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath feet minimal, slight cutout edge softness around figure, appears composited/flat against window plane light
217w57th_living0 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 75 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's feet/lower legs overlap with the stool/ottoman in front, so furniture intersects with the body instead of clear open floor · Slight flatness/cutout look to the figure against the bright window light
gemini: stands on furniture
217w57th_living0 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 69 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears slightly flat/cutout-like with limited grounding shadow · lighting on presenter doesn't fully match warm interior light direction
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match the room's ambient light · Shadow under presenter is weak, making him look slightly pasted on
217w57th_living0 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 73 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: stools appear positioned oddly close to/behind presenter's legs, slight edge overlap with ottoman · shadow/lighting on presenter slightly inconsistent with strong window backlight in room
gemini: Presenter's lighting (frontal, studio) does not match the room's lighting (bright, ambient light from windows). · Shadow under presenter is too hard and dark for the scene, making the composite look less natural.
2090madisonave_bathroom4 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: shoes obscured by baseboard heater/toilet base slightly overlapping feet area · shadow/grounding minimal but placement plausible
gemini: Presenter is standing behind/inside the toilet and radiator · Presenter's feet and lower legs are occluded by fixtures
2090madisonave_kitchen3 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 77 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Room was widened to fit presenter · Floor was artificially extended/cloned under the presenter
2090madisonave_bathroom4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 78 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's feet are not visible/grounded near toilet, appears to overlap toilet area · Person stands very close to toilet with legs partially obscured, suggesting overlap with fixture · Slight flat cutout appearance against window/wall plane
gemini: Room has been horizontally stretched, making it appear wider than the original.
2090madisonave_bathroom4 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 87 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's body overlaps/blocks toilet, appears to stand behind it rather than on clear open floor with both lower legs visible · presenter positioned very close to window/wall plane, limited natural floor space around feet
gemini: Room framing was widened on the left and right · Reflection in mirror was altered · Walls and surfaces were cleaned up/retouched
2090madisonave_bedroom2 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 43 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet overlap onto the rug and appear to sink into/behind the bed's footprint area, standing too close to the bed edge · Slight floating appearance due to soft shadow not fully grounding the feet on the rug
2090madisonave_kitchen3 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 67 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's body overlaps/intersects the doorway opening and appears to stand partially in front of the refrigerator, blending with the transition to the next room · feet placement near threshold makes depth ambiguous, reads slightly like a pasted cutout rather than naturally standing in the kitchen
gemini: Room has been significantly widened/stretched · Altered aspect ratio · Invented new wall/floor areas on both left and right sides
2090madisonave_kitchen3 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 69 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's feet/lower legs are obscured, appears to be standing in the doorway threshold rather than fully on open floor · Ceiling fan blade appears to intersect with person's head/shoulder area, suggesting flattened depth placement · Figure has a slightly pasted-in cutout appearance against the far room's wall/doorway plane
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room. · Missing presenter reflection on refrigerator.
2090madisonave_dining1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 69 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Person appears pressed close to the window/curtain plane at the back wall rather than standing naturally in the open floor area · Lower legs partially obscured by lighting glare/shadow near window, reducing sense of grounded placement
2090madisonave_bedroom2 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 46 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter's shadow is soft/unrealistic for the strong window light.
2090madisonave_bedroom2 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 69 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter is positioned in the closet doorway, overlapping the closet opening and appearing to stand partly inside/in front of the closet threshold rather than fully on open floor · His arm/hand overlaps the closet door frame edge
2090madisonave_dining1 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 83 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: framing cropped/zoomed compared to image 1, altering room proportions · curtain/window styling shifted slightly vs original · person positioned very close to window/wall plane, reads as pasted cutout with flat lighting mismatch to room
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room · Presenter shadow is not directional
2090madisonave_living0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 54 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Room framing widened/altered vs image 1 (extra wall space and different crop showing more of hallway and window) · Presenter's feet not visible, appears to float without clear ground contact · Coffee table edge is close to presenter's legs suggesting slight overlap/depth conflict
gemini: Presenter lighting and shadow do not perfectly match the room.
2090madisonave_dining1 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 126 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet are cropped out of frame at bottom edge, violating requirement to see both feet/lower legs · Figure appears pasted with slightly flat lighting compared to the warm sunlit room, giving a cutout look · Feet not visible so cannot confirm grounding on floor
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room lighting · Presenter's shadow is unconvincing
2090madisonave_living0 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 80 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: framing widened/zoomed out slightly compared to image 1, altering crop · person's feet obscured by rug texture but generally on open floor · shadow beneath presenter minimal, slightly flat lighting integration
sonnet: feet/lower legs slightly obscured by rug edge but otherwise standing on open floor
gemini: Room has been widened/stretched horizontally, distorting the perspective and changing the framing.
205e63rd_amenity3 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 77 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Right side wall extended/reshaped with added dark doorway/panel not present in image 1 · Bench on right wall shifted position and floor plant moved compared to original · Presenter appears oversized relative to nearby bench and plant pot
gemini: Presenter lighting doesn't match room · Presenter color/grain doesn't match room
205e63rd_living4 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 57 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Ceiling and top of image artificially darkened · Room appears wider/distorted
205e63rd_living4 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 61 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
205e63rd_living4 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 61 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter is positioned partially in front of/overlapping the radiator cover under the window · radiator cover intersects with legs area, breaking clear-floor placement rule
gemini: lighting on person does not match room
205e63rd_bathroom2 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 125 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: extra wall/partition edge added on left side of frame not present in original photo · framing/crop altered from portrait toilet-sink view to slightly different composition · presenter's arm overlaps the sink area, blurring boundary between figure and fixture
205e63rd_amenity3 / letterbox · t2 PASS
fid 64 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow/lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room's ambient lighting, giving a slightly pasted look · presenter stands very close to potted plant edge on right
205e63rd_amenity3 / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 46 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's feet are not visible/planted on floor, appears to float slightly · Person is positioned very close to camera compared to rest of scene, creating slight depth mismatch · Small black storage cube/table partially near presenter's leg area could imply slight overlap with foreground object
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room environment · Shadow under presenter is artificial
205e63rd_bathroom2 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 106 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's body overlaps/intersects the glass shower door and toilet area, standing partially inside the shower enclosure line rather than fully on clear open floor · Feet/lower legs partially obscured by toilet in foreground
gemini: lighting mismatch · weak shadows
205e63rd_bedroom1 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 77 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
205e63rd_bathroom2 / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 137 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's feet/lower legs obscured by toilet and pedestal sink in foreground · toilet and sink are between camera and presenter, violating clear-floor requirement · person appears slightly flat/pasted against the shower glass and wall plane
gemini: Missing reflection in mirror · Lighting on presenter does not match room · Incorrect shadows
205e63rd_bedroom1 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 68 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears slightly flat/cutout with soft edge lighting mismatch versus room ambiance · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room lighting · Presenter appears as a flat cutout due to lighting mismatch
205e63rd_bedroom1 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 112 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Presenter is missing floor shadows, appears to float · Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room lighting
205e63rd_living0 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 53 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: coffee table edge appears to slightly overlap presenter's leg/foot area, suggesting shallow depth placement · shadow beneath presenter is soft/minimal compared to strong window light, slightly reducing grounding realism
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room · Shadow is artificial
205e63rd_living0 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 60 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Coffee table overlaps/intersects with presenter's legs, meaning furniture is between camera and part of the person · Lower legs partially occluded by coffee table rather than fully visible on clear floor
gemini: missing presenter reflection in coffee table
205e63rd_living0 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 102 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: coffee table appears to overlap with presenter's legs/feet, placing furniture between camera and lower body · feet not clearly visible on floor due to coffee table intersection
gemini: Lighting on presenter is slightly inconsistent with room · Shadow under presenter is generic
20clintonst_kitchen1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 94 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: ceiling light fixture changed from flush-mount ring to different chrome fixture · kitchen counter/cabinet details simplified vs original · overall lighting/contrast flattened compared to original photo
20clintonst_kitchen1 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 81 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: subtle drop shadow but no ground contact shadow rendered, giving slight cutout/floating look · otherwise consistent with reference room and outfit
20clintonst_kitchen1 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 125 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: Person's shadow inconsistent with room lighting direction · Slight flatness in compositing gives a cutout-like appearance · Feet placement near floor transition looks slightly ambiguous
20clintonst_bedroom0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 122 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: feet/lower legs obscured by rug texture blending · rug edge appears slightly altered near desk chair
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and does not match room lighting · Shadow under presenter is generic and does not match light source
20clintonst_bedroom0 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 69 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: lower legs and feet obscured by bed, so not fully visible on open floor · shadow/grounding beneath feet is minimal, slight floating appearance
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room · Presenter casts no shadow
20clintonst_bedroom0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 125 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's feet are placed on the rug but the desk/chair area is close behind at same depth; lower legs are visible but shadow/contact with floor is weak, giving a slightly floating appearance
15hudsonyards_office4 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 87 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's legs overlap/intersect with the desk and chair, which are between the presenter and the camera · Placement not fully on clear open floor as chair and desk edge intersect with figure
15hudsonyards_office4 / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 96 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's body overlaps/intersects the desk and chair rather than standing fully on clear open floor · legs partially obscured by furniture between presenter and camera
gemini: changed crop/framing · room has been horizontally extended/widened
15hudsonyards_office4 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 113 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: added curtain/window on left side not present in original photo · added door on right side not present in original photo · room framing widened beyond original crop to accommodate new elements
gemini: camera framing changed · room was extended/widened
15hudsonyards_bedroom3 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 69 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
15hudsonyards_bedroom3 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 100 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person stands directly in front of chairs at similar depth, minor rug shadow mismatch, otherwise consistent
15hudsonyards_kitchen1 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 115 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: kitchen island/counter is between presenter's lower body and camera, obscuring feet/legs · shadow beneath presenter appears inconsistent with natural standing contact, giving slight cutout/pasted look
sonnet: Presenter's lower legs/feet are obscured by the armchair in front of him, breaking the 'both feet visible / no furniture between subject and camera' requirement · Slight cutout/flat-paste look due to lighting mismatch with the warm ambient room light
15hudsonyards_dining2 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 72 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: table edge and legs intersect presenter's body/legs, standing behind furniture rather than on fully clear floor · lower legs partially occluded by dining table
gemini: room was widened/altered · presenter behind furniture
15hudsonyards_dining2 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 115 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter appears oversized relative to dining table and chairs, which are at similar depth · Chair in foreground overlaps/intersects with presenter's leg, and table edge is near presenter's body suggesting furniture is between/around him rather than clear floor space · Presenter's feet/lower legs are not clearly visible due to proximity to chair
15hudsonyards_dining2 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 66 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Chair leg and rush seat overlap/intersect with presenter's legs, placing furniture between camera and subject · Lower legs partially occluded by dining chair in foreground
gemini: presenter is behind furniture
15hudsonyards_kitchen1 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 76 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's legs appear to overlap/be obscured near the kitchen island area, with island counter close behind creating ambiguity of depth placement · Shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with strong window light, making the figure read slightly like a pasted cutout
gemini: invented/extended wall and floor on far right to make space for presenter
15hudsonyards_living0 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 56 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet obscured by armchair in foreground, breaking 'fully on clear open floor' requirement · Cutout edges around figure appear slightly soft/pasted-in, reducing natural integration into the depth of the room
gemini: Presenter looks pasted on due to lighting mismatch
15hudsonyards_kitchen1 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 55 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet are obscured, appearing to stand behind/through the kitchen island counter · Feet not visible, contact with floor unclear · Slight flat cutout appearance due to lighting mismatch with room
gemini: Presenter lighting is inconsistent with room lighting · Presenter lacks floor reflections
15hudsonyards_living0 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 52 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person is standing with a chair/stool directly behind and partially overlapping their legs, and their feet appear to be occluded/intersecting the low wooden chair in front of the staircase · Lower legs not fully visible due to furniture overlap · Slight floating/pasted-cutout appearance with soft shadow not fully matching floor contact
145w86th_dining0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 86 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Virtually Staged watermark text removed from image 2 compared to image 1
145w86th_dining0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 78 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: feet partially obscured by carpet shadow but otherwise fine
gemini: Presenter appears like a flat cutout due to lighting that is inconsistent with the room. · Presenter lacks a shadow to ground them on the floor, making them appear pasted on.
145w86th_dining0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 114 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's legs/feet overlap with the front dining chair, placing furniture between them and the camera · Person appears pasted with slightly flat lighting/shadow compared to room · Watermark 'Virtually Staged' still present
gemini: watermark not removed
123e61st_amenity4 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 60 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: exercise mat and bench appear slightly obscured behind presenter's legs, minor depth ambiguity · shadow beneath presenter is faint, slightly reducing grounding realism
gemini: Missing presenter's reflection in mirror
123e61st_amenity4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 84 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter is standing on top of the round mini trampoline, feet not on clear open floor · Lower legs/feet partially obscured by trampoline frame · Slight cutout/pasted appearance with soft edges around figure
gemini: Presenter is standing on a trampoline, not on open floor.
123e61st_amenity4 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 56 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
123e61st_bedroom2 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 73 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter minimal/inconsistent with room lighting · otherwise faithful room and correct wardrobe match
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting · cutout edges around presenter appear slightly soft, suggesting composite
gemini: Presenter is lit with harsh frontal light that conflicts with the room's soft, ambient lighting. · Shadow at presenter's feet is too dark and sharp, not matching the scene's shadows.
123e61st_hallway1 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 62 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
123e61st_bedroom2 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with room lighting · feet placement near rug edge slightly ambiguous but appears on floor
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room · Shadows unrealistic
123e61st_bedroom2 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 64 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person's legs overlap the bed/bench in front, no clear gap showing feet fully on open floor · shadow direction inconsistent with room lighting, giving slightly pasted-in look
gemini: Presenter shadow is unrealistic · Lighting on presenter does not match room lighting
123e61st_living0 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 93 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's legs are obscured by the coffee table and books, breaking the 'no furniture between subject and camera' and 'both feet/lower legs visible' requirement · Slight flatness in lighting on figure compared to warm room ambiance suggests a pasted-in look
gemini: Slightly weak shadow under presenter
123e61st_living0 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 67 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: coffee table and books overlap presenter's legs, placing furniture between him and camera · feet/lower legs partially obscured by table · figure reads slightly like a flat cutout due to lighting mismatch with room
gemini: Lighting on presenter is flat and does not match the room's lighting · Shadow at presenter's feet is a simple drop shadow, not realistic
123e61st_living0 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 87 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet are obscured by the coffee table and sectional, breaking the 'both feet visible, no furniture between' requirement · Shadow beneath figure looks pasted/inconsistent with room lighting, contributing to a cutout appearance
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room · Presenter's shadow is unconvincing
123e61st_hallway1 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 59 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Presenter lighting mismatch
101warrenst_hallway3 / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 65 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Presenter's right side overlaps/stands in front of the right dresser, with foot appearing to intersect the base of the dresser · No clear gap shown between presenter's leg and the furniture edge, reading as slightly merged with the chest of drawers
101warrenst_kitchen4 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 92 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Person appears slightly flat/pasted with soft edges against doorway · Slight lighting mismatch between presenter and warm ambient room tones
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room · Presenter casts no shadow
101warrenst_kitchen4 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 77 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: feet/lower legs partially obscured by island shadow area but appear on open floor · person's cast lighting slightly inconsistent with warm ambient room light
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and from the front, not matching the warm overhead and cool window light sources in the room. · The unnatural lighting and soft, generic shadow make the presenter look like a cutout pasted onto the image.
101warrenst_kitchen4 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 91 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person stands close to doorway/cabinet edge but appears on open floor area · slight flatness suggesting composited cutout with soft edge lighting mismatch
gemini: The frontal lighting on the presenter does not match the warm, overhead ambient lighting of the room, making him look like a flat cutout pasted into the scene.
101warrenst_hallway3 / letterbox · t2 PASS
fid 86 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: chair partially hidden behind presenter, slight overlap with legs
gemini: lighting on person does not match room
101warrenst_hallway3 / letterbox · t3 PASS
fid 74 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Presenter overlaps furniture
101warrenst_living0 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 35 · sonnet pass · gemini —
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with strong directional light in scene · slight flatness/cutout quality to presenter's edges suggesting composited look
101warrenst_dining2 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 73 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person's proportions/lighting appear slightly flat/pasted compared to scene depth, giving a cutout appearance · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with strong directional lighting in room
gemini: Presenter lighting is harsh and inconsistent with the warm, ambient room lighting.
101warrenst_dining2 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 56 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: figure appears slightly flat/cutout-like against the paneled wall, lighting on person doesn't fully match warm ambient tones of room · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting
gemini: presenter partially behind furniture · lighting on presenter does not match room
101warrenst_dining2 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 48 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: table/bench edge intersects presenter's lower legs, blocking view of feet · presenter positioned directly behind dining table, not on clear open floor · slight flat cutout appearance due to lack of grounding shadow
gemini: Presenter placed behind furniture · Presenter's legs are partially obscured by the table · Presenter has no reflection on the highly reflective tabletop
101warrenst_amenity1 / letterbox · t2 PASS
fid 94 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: feet/lower legs partially obscured by shadow area but position appears grounded on floor near sculpture, slight proximity to sculpture edge · otherwise consistent with reference
gemini: Presenter lighting and shadow do not match the scene
101warrenst_amenity1 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 154 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's arm/hand overlaps the striped sculpture, and his body is positioned directly against the furniture rather than on fully clear floor · figure reads slightly flat/cutout-like against the window plane, lacking natural cast shadow consistent with the strong directional light in the scene
gemini: Room was widened · Changed crop/framing
101warrenst_amenity1 / letterbox · t1 PASS
fid 95 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: frame/crop of image 2 narrower than image 1, image widened with black bars and added canvas rather than true original framing · person placed at edge with feet near frame boundary, slightly compressed depth relative to floor pattern
gemini: Presenter lighting is frontal, mismatched with the room's strong backlighting
101warrenst_living0 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: subtle drop shadow but figure edge slightly soft/cutout-like against floor · otherwise consistent placement and lighting
gemini: Artist signature/watermark removed from left wall panel.
101warrenst_living0 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 122 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Image cropped/zoomed compared to original wide framing, changing composition · Dog appears facing opposite direction and slightly repositioned · Right side sofa area and some background elements cropped out of frame
gemini: image framing is wider · art panel/wall on left has been extended · dog's collar has been added/colorized
215e19b_living4 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 82 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: feet partially obscured by rug edge but overall placement acceptable · slight softness in cast shadow but not critical
gemini: Lighting on presenter is brighter and harsher than room's ambient light. · Shadow under presenter is weak and doesn't match room lighting. · Slight smudging on wall around presenter's outline.
215e19b_living4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 78 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's legs/feet overlap into the sofa area, appears to be standing partially behind/against the couch rather than fully on clear open floor
gemini: Room has been widened · Changed crop/framing · Presenter is standing on the sofa
215e19b_living4 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 77 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Sofa arm overlaps/intersects presenter's leg, meaning furniture is between him and full clear floor space · Presenter's feet not clearly grounded with visible separation from sofa, appears close to touching/overlapping furniture edge
gemini: Lighting on presenter doesn't match room · Presenter casts no shadow
215e19b_living3 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 93 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: ottoman overlaps/intersects with presenter's legs, standing directly behind furniture instead of clear open floor · lower legs partially obscured by ottoman in foreground
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room · Weak shadow on floor
215e19b_dining1 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 104 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: chair from dining set overlaps/intersects presenter's legs, placing furniture between camera and subject · lower legs partially obscured by chair · shadow beneath presenter looks pasted/flat suggesting cutout compositing
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and inconsistent with the room's light sources · Unrealistic shadows under presenter's feet · Presenter looks like a flat cutout pasted into the scene
215e19b_bedroom2 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 85 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room lighting · Shadow is unrealistic and artificial
215e19b_dining1 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 101 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Room walls near camera were extended/altered, narrowing the entryway compared to image 1's original framing · Person cast shadow suggests standing on floor but appears slightly close to camera edge, feet cropped at very bottom · Overall room proportions changed - side walls added closer to camera that don't exist in original
gemini: Room widened / framing changed · Presenter image was horizontally flipped · Unrealistic lighting and shadow on presenter
215e19b_bedroom2 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 55 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: lighting on person does not match room · person looks like a cutout · shadow is generic
215e19b_living0 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 62 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
215e19b_living0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 39 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's feet are positioned right at the edge of the herringbone floor transition, appearing to stand partially on the cowhide rug edge which is at a different depth than the clear hallway floor · Person placement reads slightly like a flat cutout due to hard edge lighting mismatch with the softer ambient light in the hallway
gemini: Missing reflection in oven · Lighting on presenter is slightly too bright and frontal vs room lighting
215e19b_dining1 / letterbox · t1 PASS
fid 68 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter appears artificial/inconsistent with room lighting · slight softness/blur mismatch at feet suggesting cutout compositing
gemini: Lighting on presenter is too flat and doesn't match the room's light sources (windows). · Shadow under presenter is generic and not well integrated.
215e19b_living0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 87 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: feet partially obscured by rug edge/shadow, but otherwise fine · lower legs slightly ambiguous against herringbone floor transition
161hudson2_living4 / lit · t1 PASS
fid 71 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Presenter's lighting is inconsistent with the room's lighting · Presenter lacks convincing contact shadows, making feet appear to float
161hudson2_living4 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 59 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's feet and lower legs are occluded by the chair/ottoman in front, appears to be standing inside furniture rather than on clear open floor · Furniture (armchair) is between the person and camera, violating placement rule
gemini: Presenter is standing on furniture · Presenter is scaled too small
161hudson2_bathroom3 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 108 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: A door was added on the right side that doesn't exist in image 1, altering the room architecture · The rug and floor shadow beneath the presenter appear inconsistent, suggesting a pasted cutout look · Framing/crop of the room differs slightly from image 1, showing more wall/door on the right than the original
gemini: Door added on right wall
161hudson2_living4 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 60 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs/feet overlap and intersect with the front chair/ottoman, meaning furniture is between the camera and the person's lower body · Feet not fully visible on clear open floor
gemini: Presenter is standing on top of a chair, not on the floor.
161hudson2_bathroom3 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 110 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's legs overlap/intersect with the vanity cabinet and shower bench area, not fully on clear open floor · Person reads as a flatly pasted cutout with inconsistent lighting/shadow compared to the room · No visible cast shadow grounding the figure on the floor
gemini: missing presenter's reflection in mirror · missing presenter's reflection in shower glass
161hudson2_kitchen1 / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 47 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs and lower body are occluded by the kitchen island, violating the requirement that no furniture be between them and the camera · Person stands partially behind the island rather than fully on clear open floor
gemini: Presenter overlaps with furniture · Presenter positioned behind stool
161hudson2_bedroom2 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 81 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: camera framing/crop changed slightly vs image 1, showing more ceiling/right wall area · presenter appears slightly oversized relative to door and bench at same depth
gemini: room has been widened on right · invented window on right
161hudson2_bedroom2 / lit · t2 PASS
fid 63 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow direction inconsistent with room lighting · feet slightly obscured by rug edge but otherwise floor placement acceptable
gemini: Unrealistic presenter shadow
161hudson2_bathroom3 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 106 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Person's lower legs/feet overlap in front of the vanity cabinet and baskets, with the cabinet appearing to sit behind him but his feet are obscured by the rug edge/vanity base, making foot placement ambiguous · Figure appears slightly flat/cutout-like against the busy tiled wall, lacking fully natural shadow cast on floor consistent with room lighting
gemini: Floor mat was replaced · Presenter's reflection is missing in mirror · Presenter's reflection is missing in shower glass
161hudson2_bedroom2 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 67 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs/feet overlap with the bench in front of the bed, breaking the 'clear open floor' requirement · Lower legs are partially obscured by the storage bench furniture
gemini: Ceiling architecture was altered/extended upwards
161hudson2_kitchen1 / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 101 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Kitchen island counter overlaps/intersects the presenter's body, placing furniture between camera and person · Lower legs and feet are partially obscured by the island, violating full lower-leg visibility requirement · Shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting, contributing to a slightly pasted-in look
gemini: Added a rug · Presenter overlaps furniture
161hudson2_living0 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 121 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: hallway opening behind presenter appears added compared to image 1 · shadow/lighting on presenter doesn't fully match room's soft window light · person's edges show slight cutout softness
gemini: Lighting on presenter doesn't match room · Presenter shadow is weak/unrealistic
161hudson2_kitchen1 / lit · t1 gate_fail
fid 65 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's legs overlap/intersect with the kitchen island, which is between him and the camera · Lower legs partially obscured by island, violating full leg visibility requirement
gemini: Presenter lacks a shadow · Lighting on presenter is flat and does not match the room's light sources
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room lighting · Presenter lacks a realistic shadow · Presenter looks like a flat cutout
161hudson2_living0 / lit · t3 PASS
fid 72 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: lower legs partially obscured by armchair in foreground · shadow beneath presenter appears minimal, slightly flat lighting integration
kitchen / lit · t1 PASS
fid 92 · sonnet pass · gemini —
kitchen / lit · t2 gate_fail
fid 101 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Left wall/opening area altered - a dark vertical strip/edge and partial doorway added on far left compared to image 1, changing the room's framing/architecture · Person's legs are partially obscured by kitchen island counter, breaking the 'clear open floor, no furniture between subject and camera' requirement · Overall camera framing slightly shifted left relative to image 1
kitchen / lit · t3 gate_fail
fid 92 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: room width/framing altered - left side shows extra wall/doorway not present in original crop · stainless island panel geometry near presenter looks slightly extended, and presenter's leg overlaps into island edge area, obscuring lower leg/foot clarity · kitchen cabinetry framing shifted slightly left compared to original photo, indicating recomposition rather than pure addition of person
sonnet: far window/couch area appears slightly rearranged with sofa shifted and rug edges altered vs image 1 · framing crop is nearly identical but left-side floor transition line looks slightly repositioned
gemini: Lighting on the presenter is slightly flat compared to the scene. · Presenter lacks a strong, realistic shadow consistent with the room's lighting.
r3_living / lit · t4 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is inconsistent with room lighting, giving a slightly pasted-in look · otherwise placement and scale are plausible
gemini: Unrealistic shadow under presenter · Presenter lighting does not match room lighting
r3_living / lit · t1 PASS
fid 73 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person's cast shadow on floor is minimal/inconsistent with strong directional light from window · edges around figure show slight cutout/matte halo suggesting flat pasted composite
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room lighting · Presenter casts no shadow
r3_living / lit · t3 PASS
fid 85 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is faint/inconsistent with strong window light direction · feet placement slightly ambiguous relative to rug edge, but on open floor
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room lighting · Presenter shadow is weak/inconsistent with light source
r3_living / lit · t2 PASS
fid 77 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person stands on transition strip near rug edge, slight shadow inconsistency with room lighting
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match scene lighting · Presenter's shadow is unrealistic for the strong directional light
tub_portrait / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 94 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Room framing/architecture changed: image 2 shows a wider space with an added glass door and wall panel not present in image 1's tight bathroom crop · Camera angle and room proportions differ from image 1, appears extended/reshaped · Presenter is oversized relative to the tub and bench, looks too large for the room depth
gemini: Room was significantly widened · Scene was extended on both sides · A new door was added on the right
tub_portrait / letterbox · t4 PASS
fid 88 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: feet/lower legs slightly obscured by tile grout shadow but plausible · person stands close to tub edge, slight proximity but not overlapping · overall placement reads as pasted cutout with soft edge lighting mismatch
gemini: presenter looks like a cutout · lighting mismatch · poor shadows
tub_portrait / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 81 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Framing/crop widened compared to image 1, revealing more wall on left side not present in original · Presenter appears to stand partially behind/at the same depth as the tub with no clear floor gap, feet not clearly visible on open floor · Person placement between tub and bench feels cramped, tub edge close to his legs suggesting slight overlap in depth
gemini: Room has been artificially widened/extended · Changed crop/framing
tub_portrait / letterbox · t5 gate_fail
fid 125 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Room was un-cropped/widened · Walls, ceiling, and floor were extended/invented · Camera framing changed
tub_portrait / letterbox · t1 PASS
fid 93 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
tub_portrait / primary · t5 gate_fail
fid 113 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: room crop widened/reframed compared to image 1, showing more wall than original · tub appears shortened/repositioned relative to original framing · presenter's feet not visible, ambiguous floor contact
gemini: Presenter lighting mismatch · Shadows under feet are weak
tub_portrait / primary · t4 gate_fail
fid 116 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter is standing in the shower/tub area where a wooden bench is directly behind/beside his legs, appearing to intersect his lower body · Feet placement overlaps with the tub/bench zone rather than fully clear open floor · Person's stance and lighting look slightly pasted-in relative to the wet-area surfaces
gemini: Room has been widened/extended · Changed aspect ratio/framing · Presenter looks like a flat cutout due to inconsistent lighting
tub_portrait / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 120 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter's feet/legs are cropped by the tub, appearing to stand partially behind it rather than fully on open floor · Person is positioned close to the tub, slightly overlapping its edge in the frame
gemini: room widened · invented walls/floor · changed aspect ratio
tub_portrait / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 129 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Second shower head and additional towel bar added to right wall, not present in image 1 · Bench appears shifted/resized relative to original · Presenter's feet are obscured/cropped near tub, not fully visible on open floor
gemini: Room was horizontally stretched · Altered camera framing/field of view · Invented new image area on left
tub_portrait / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 133 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Room framing widened/cropped differently from image 1 (aspect ratio and zoom changed) · Bathtub position and wall proportions shifted compared to original, suggesting the room was extended/reflowed rather than matched exactly · Presenter's feet are not visible, cut off at floor level
gemini: Presenter is standing inside a shower stall · Presenter's shadow is weak and unrealistic · Lighting on presenter does not match room
vanity / primary · t5 gate_fail
fid 75 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Presenter appears only as a reflection in the mirror, not standing in the actual room space · Lower legs and feet not visible, presenter cropped at waist in mirror reflection · Person reads as a flat inserted reflection rather than naturally standing in the room
gemini: Presenter is only visible in a reflection · Presenter is partially obscured by the vanity in the reflection · Presenter's feet and lower legs are not visible
vanity / primary · t4 gate_fail
fid 97 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Wall paneling/tile texture altered behind presenter compared to image 1 · Electrical outlets/switch plates changed in style and position vs original · Presenter's feet obscure lower cabinet/floor transition, unclear if standing on open floor
gemini: Invented/extended wood paneling on left wall
vanity / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 87 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Vanity countertop and cabinet appear to be behind the presenter at similar depth but his feet are not visible and lower legs are cut off by the vanity, making it appear he is standing inside/behind the vanity rather than clearly on open floor · feet not visible
gemini: presenter has no reflection in the large mirror directly behind him
vanity / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 119 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: person's feet overlap/obscure the vanity toe-kick area, standing too close to the counter as if partially behind it · lower legs partially cut off by floor shadow area, reducing clear visibility of feet · person stands very near cabinetry edge rather than fully on open clear floor
gemini: Room artificially widened to the left to make space for the presenter · The wall, wood paneling, countertop, and mirror have all been extended to the left · Wall hook removed from left wall
vanity / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 103 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Wood paneling on the left wall has been extended much higher than in the original photo, covering stone tile area that should remain visible - an invented/restyled architectural element
gemini: Room widened · Invented/extended wall and wainscoting on left
r3_living / minimal · t5 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter inconsistent with light direction from window · slight flatness/cutout appearance of presenter against background
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room · Shadow under presenter is unrealistic for the scene's lighting
r3_living / minimal · t3 PASS
fid 68 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: lower legs/feet partially obscured by rug shadow but generally visible · person stands close to column, slight depth ambiguity
gemini: presenter looks like a flat cutout · lighting on presenter does not match room lighting · presenter shadow is incorrect for the scene
r3_living / minimal · t4 gate_fail
fid 109 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person appears pasted/composited with slightly inconsistent lighting compared to room · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with strong window light in scene
gemini: Presenter lighting doesn't match the scene's hard sunlight · Shadow under presenter is too soft and diffuse
r3_living / minimal · t2 PASS
fid 68 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears slightly flat/cutout-like with soft edge halo suggesting pasted composite rather than naturally integrated lighting/shadow on floor
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match the room · Unrealistic shadow under presenter
r3_living / primary · t5 gate_fail
fid 71 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Crop/framing changed from image 1 to image 2 (wider aspect ratio, more ceiling/floor visible) · Person appears oversized relative to the sofa and window mullions at similar depth · Person is placed on a raised wood platform/step at the very edge of frame near the window, reading as pasted rather than standing naturally in the room's main floor area
gemini: poor lighting integration · presenter's shadow is weak/unrealistic
r3_living / minimal · t1 PASS
fid 67 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: figure appears slightly flat/cutout-like with soft edge halo suggesting compositing rather than natural integration · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting
gemini: Inconsistent lighting on presenter · Presenter shadow is incorrect for scene
r3_living / primary · t1 PASS
fid 71 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: lighting on presenter does not match room · presenter lacks realistic shadow
r3_living / primary · t4 PASS
fid 72 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: shadow beneath feet appears minimal/inconsistent with strong window light, giving slightly pasted-in look · otherwise placement on rug and floor is plausible
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match scene · Unrealistic shadow at feet · Presenter looks pasted in
r3_living / primary · t3 PASS
fid 60 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person appears slightly flat/cutout-like against window light with soft edge halo, giving a pasted-in look · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with strong directional light in room
gemini: Mismatched lighting on presenter · Unrealistic shadows
r3_living / primary · t2 PASS
fid 54 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: person's shadow/lighting is inconsistent with the harsh window light in the room · slight flatness/cutout appearance to the presenter compared to scene lighting
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not match room's light source · Shadow under presenter is generic and unrealistic
161hudson_bathroom4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 104 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: A door was added on the right side that is not present in image 1 · Person's leg overlaps/intersects the vanity cabinet in front of him · Person appears to float slightly above the rug/floor line
gemini: A closed door was added on the right · Mirror reflections have been altered/removed
161hudson_bathroom4 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 109 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Feet/lower legs obscured by white bath mat, appears to stand partially on it rather than fully visible on clear floor · Person positioned very close to vanity counter, minor spatial crowding
gemini: room was extended/widened · changed camera framing · invented wall space left of shower
161hudson_bathroom4 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 113 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Image 2 added a door on the right wall that doesn't exist in image 1, and cropped/reframed the shot wider than the original · Presenter's feet are obscured/blend into the bath mat and vanity area, no clear floor gap between him and camera · Room framing extended beyond original photo boundaries, inventing wall space not present in image 1
gemini: Added a door on the right wall
161hudson_bedroom3 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 57 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter inconsistent with room lighting · edge slightly soft around figure suggesting cutout paste
gemini: Presenter lighting is flat and doesn't match room lighting · Presenter's shadow is weak and unrealistic
161hudson_bedroom3 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 84 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow direction of presenter inconsistent with room lighting · presenter appears slightly flat/cutout against wall
161hudson_bedroom3 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 73 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
gemini: Lighting on presenter doesn't match room lighting · Presenter's shadow is weak/missing, slightly affecting grounding
161hudson_kitchen2 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 75 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: presenter's legs/feet are obscured by the kitchen island, indicating overlap with furniture between camera and subject · lower legs and feet not fully visible due to island in front
gemini: Room was horizontally stretched/widened · Presenter is missing a floor shadow · Presenter lighting does not match scene lighting
161hudson_kitchen2 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 63 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: Left wall extended/invented · Artwork added to left wall · Presenter lighting does not match room
161hudson_dining1 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 127 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: chairs are positioned between presenter and camera, overlapping his legs/lower body · one chair partially intersects his leg area
gemini: presenter standing on furniture · room widened · invented new space on left
161hudson_kitchen2 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 89 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: person's lower body overlaps/intersects the kitchen island and bar stools, feet not visible on clear open floor · furniture (island) is between camera and part of the presenter, breaking depth logic
gemini: Room artificially widened on both sides · Doorway on left removed/replaced with wall
161hudson_dining1 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 120 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: A hallway with a door was added on the left side of image 2 that does not exist in image 1, extending/altering the room layout · Camera framing is wider/zoomed out compared to image 1, revealing new architecture not present in original · Presenter's legs partially obscured behind the column and appear close to overlapping dining chairs, placement not fully on clear open floor
gemini: room was extended/outpainted on the left
161hudson_living0 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 58 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: person's lower legs and feet are occluded by the coffee table and armchair in front, so not fully visible standing on clear floor · furniture (chairs/table) is between the presenter and the camera
gemini: Presenter is standing on furniture · Presenter scale is too large
161hudson_living0 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 70 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Presenter's lower legs/feet are occluded by the small round side table and armchair in front of him · Person appears to be standing partially behind/inside the furniture arrangement rather than on clear open floor · Feet not visible
gemini: Lighting on person does not match room · Shadow is unrealistic
161hudson_dining1 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 119 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Image 2 shows a wider framing/crop revealing a hallway and door on the left that is not visible in image 1, indicating the room view was extended rather than matching the original camera framing exactly
gemini: Room was widened/extended on the left · Changed camera framing
161hudson_living0 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 78 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: person's lower legs/feet occluded by armchair and ottoman in front, appears to stand inside/behind the furniture rather than on clear open floor
gemini: presenter is standing on a chair
215e19_bathroom4 / primary · t2 gate_fail
fid 110 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
215e19_bathroom4 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 77 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
gemini: missing reflection in mirror
215e19_bedroom3 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 81 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: Slight shadow beneath presenter looks somewhat abrupt, but overall placement and scale appear plausible
gemini: Presenter looks pasted on, lacking realistic shadows and lighting integration.
215e19_bathroom4 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 123 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: A door was added on the left wall that is not present in the original image 1, altering the room's architecture.
gemini: A door was added to the left side of the image · The room was horizontally extended/invented on the left
215e19_bedroom3 / primary · t3 gate_fail
fid 54 · sonnet FAIL · gemini pass ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person stands with feet on rug but positioned very close to dresser edge, minor depth ambiguity near right side furniture · shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting, giving slight cutout appearance
215e19_bedroom3 / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 79 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Feet cast shadow on rug but figure appears slightly cutout/pasted against wall/window area · Positioned close to dresser edge, minor depth ambiguity
gemini: Lighting on presenter is inconsistent with room · Presenter's shadow is unnatural · Presenter looks like a flat cutout
215e19_dining2 / letterbox · t2 gate_fail
fid 86 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Left wall extended/enlarged compared to image 1, altering room framing/crop · Presenter's legs overlap with dining chair, furniture intersects lower body · Person stands very close to table with chair between them and camera path
gemini: Room extended on left · Framing changed
215e19_dining2 / letterbox · t1 PASS
fid 90 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter looks slightly artificial/disconnected from floor · presenter positioned close to door frame but not overlapping
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room · Shadow is generic and inconsistent with room lighting
215e19_dining2 / letterbox · t3 gate_fail
fid 117 · sonnet FAIL · gemini FAIL
sonnet: Image 2 has narrower crop/framing with added side wall panels not in image 1 · Person's feet obscured/blending near table and rug edge, unclear ground contact · Figure reads slightly pasted-in with soft edge halo against window/doorway area
sonnet: Presenter's feet/lower legs overlap with the round coffee table in the foreground, placing furniture between the person and the camera · Person stands partially in the hallway threshold area rather than fully on open floor
215e19_living1 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 50 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
215e19_living1 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 57 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting · slight flat cutout appearance at edges
gemini: Lighting on presenter does not perfectly match the room's lighting · Shadows beneath presenter are slightly unnatural
215e19_kitchen0 / primary · t3 PASS
fid 76 · sonnet pass · gemini FAIL ⚠ disagree
sonnet: person appears as a flat pasted cutout with slightly inconsistent lighting/shadow compared to the room, but no room alterations detected
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room environment · Shadow is unrealistic / poorly integrated · Presenter looks like a flat cutout
215e19_kitchen0 / primary · t1 PASS
fid 58 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: slight flat cutout appearance/lighting mismatch with scene · shadow beneath presenter minimal/inconsistent with room lighting
215e19_kitchen0 / primary · t2 PASS
fid 61 · sonnet pass · gemini pass
sonnet: shadow beneath presenter is minimal/inconsistent with room lighting · slight softness/edge blending around presenter suggesting composite
gemini: Presenter lighting does not match room · Missing or weak presenter shadow
kitchen / primary · t1 gate_fail
fid 110 · sonnet pass · gemini —
r4_bedroom / primary · t3 PASS
fid 62 · sonnet pass · gemini —
r4_bedroom / primary · t2 PASS
fid 71 · sonnet pass · gemini —
sonnet: a doorway is visible behind presenter that is not present/visible in image 1, indicating slight alteration to wall · presenter's shadow/grounding on floor is minimal, slightly flat cutout appearance
kitchen / primary · t5 gate_fail
fid 66 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: Lower legs/feet obscured by kitchen island edge, suggesting person is standing behind/partially through the island rather than fully on clear open floor · Person placement close to island creates ambiguity about depth relative to island
kitchen / primary · t1 PASS
fid 66 · sonnet pass · gemini —
r4_bedroom / primary · t1 PASS
fid 68 · sonnet pass · gemini —
kitchen / primary · t2 PASS
fid 53 · sonnet pass · gemini —
kitchen / primary · t3 PASS
fid 88 · sonnet pass · gemini —
kitchen / primary · t4 PASS
fid 87 · sonnet pass · gemini —
tub_portrait / letterbox · t1 gate_fail
fid 85 · sonnet FAIL · gemini —
sonnet: presenter's lower legs/feet are obscured by the bathtub, which is between him and the camera · person appears slightly flattened against the tile background rather than fully grounded in the tight space
